Places to Eat

We couldn’t possibly let you visit North Yorkshire without recommendations of some of the best places to eat! From Italian cuisine to local fish and chips, we have you covered!


Here’s our top recommendations:

Rusty Shears

Rusty Shears is a gorgeous little restaurant located on Silver Street, just a 8 minute walk from Whitby Harbour. They offer a selection of homemade cakes and pastries, speciality teas, coffees and over 150 different and unique flavours of Gin if you fancy an afternoon tipple.

The interior has a quirky Victorian feel, perfect for cosy winter days, while the summer months can be spent outside in the Mediterranean-style courtyard under their fig trees. Rusty Shears is a hidden gem in Whitby, whether you want breakfast, lunch, brunch, dinner or just a drink, it’s not to be missed.

Ditto Restaurant

If you’re looking for somewhere cosy, Ditto Restaurant is to be considered! With their fabulous dark green and wooden interior, you’ll feel the homely vibe they give off no matter what you consume.

Ditto is a small family run restaurant where you can enjoy a lovely meal in a comfortable relaxed environment. Their menu features dishes packed with flavour and assembled from fresh local produce, using British ingredients to help create dishes with influences taken from all over the world. The menu evolves throughout the year to take advantage of the best seasonal ingredients.

The Magpie Café

If you’re looking for fish & chips, there’s only one place for it! Locally known as “the best fish and chips in Yorkshire”, The Magpie Cafe is so good that even on cold winter days you’ll find a queue of people eager to taste the iconic English delicacy.

The menu features all the classic orders such as haddock and cod, but also favourites including fresh mussels or fish pie. You can either sit in the café, or head to the takeaway next door if you prefer to eat on-the-go.

Falling Foss Tea Garden

In an absolutely exquisite setting surrounded by a waterfall and forest, Falling Foss Tea Garden is the perfect quaint spot to grab a bite to eat. Self described as a rustic, outdoor setting and “picnic tables and wellington boots rather than fine china and linen tablecloths”, you’ll find simple classics here, from freshly baked scones with lashings of jam and cream, delicious homemade cakes and savoury pastries.

Cosa Nostra

Located in a spectacular grade II listed building, Cosa Nostra offers a menu of delicious Italian cuisine using fresh ingredients and high-quality produce that is locally sourced. As an independent, family run restaurant, who are passionate about food, they provide friendly and attentive service in a relaxed setting with the perfect ambience.

Are your taste buds tingling? Book a stay in Whitby today!

“

Pinot Perch

The place was absolutely gorgeous and spotless too. The bed was comfy, the rooms were spacious and the view of Whitney Abbey out of the top window was gorgeous. The host was very helpful and there is also a useful guide you can access online when you book which tells you everything you need to know about the property and the surrounding area. We would definitely book here again and recommend to friends and family.

- Nicole, England
”
“

Nancy’s Nook

This is a lovely place to stay. Walking distance into the centre. Place was pristine and one of the comfiest beds we have ever slept in. Amazing base to explore Whitby. Host very responsive and helpful. Would definitely book again.

- Ian, Liverpool
”
“

Sea Renity

The house was wonderful, it was just as the photos described and was incredibly clean. The beds were comfortable, Joanne was always responsive. The check in was exactly as described and all the instructions were super clear! It made our stay even better, thank you so much!

- Sophie
”
“

Salt & Sage

A gorgeous home. Perfect for attending an Aunt’s 80th birthday celebrations with my husband, daughter & 2 granddaughters. We know Whitby well so we’re not really there for sightseeing but if you’re a first timer to Whitby, this is a great spot to discover the town from. The house has everything needed for a home-from-home. Great to have a family bathroom plus en-suite shower/loo in the main bedroom. Beds are very comfy, especially the main bedroom. So much so that I noted the manufacturer as im looking for a new mattress at home  Parking can be a little tricky but is free and once a spot has been found, there’s no need to move if staying in the town. It is a short walk to the town centre and all amenities. Joanne was proactive in contacting me prior to our arrival and supplied a great guide to the house etc. I totally recommend this little gem of a property.

- Sarah, Middlesbrough
”

Book Direct and Save up to 20% on your stay.

No hidden fees, no middleman, just effortless luxury at the best possible price.